culture
philosophy

The State of the Modern American University

Physicist, Author
Philosophy, Mount St. Mary's
Genesis
Response
Penultimate
Finale

Lawrence Krauss

Physicist, Author

September 20th, 2020
In May 2017 Bret Weinstein and his wife were forced to resign from Evergreen State College following an outcry over his refusal to cancel his class for a day and stay off campus to show solidarity with minority students protests.
In November 2015 a mob of students at Yale University accused college master Nicholas Christakis and his wife Erika of racism following her email suggesting that Yale did not need to oversee Halloween costumes. Subsequently the University conferred graduation prizes on two of the mob members for their “service of race and ethnic relations,” and for their “anti-racist” work.
This September students at Skidmore College demanded that an art professor be fired because he and his wife went to watch a rally supporting police. The administration responded by investigating possible bias in his classes. The same month USC replaced a professor of business communication with another instructor after complaints that he explained to the class that in China, a common pause word (like “um” in English) is “that that that,” or “ne ga ne ga ne ga.”
Following the death of George Floyd, calls to “shut down STEM” in academia to fight “systemic racism” were echoed by university leaders. During one strike at Michigan State University, a group initiated a protest campaign against the VP for research, whose “crimes” consisted of doing research on computational genomics to study how human genetics might be related to cognitive ability, and supporting the research of MSU psychologists on the statistics of police shootings that didn’t provide direct support of claims of racial bias. Within a week, the university president forced the VP to resign.
In response to the protests following Floyd's death, 100 Princeton faculty proposed the creation of a faculty policing committee to “oversee the investigation and discipline of racist behaviors, incidents, research, and publication on the part of faculty,” with “racism” to be defined by another faculty committee, and requiring every department, including math, physics, astronomy, and other sciences, to establish a senior thesis prize for research that somehow “is actively anti-racist.”
Universities have created huge diversity bureaucracies that police speech as well as behavior and set up “safe spaces” to shield students from hearing debates or lectures with ideas that might offend them. Junior faculty are required to produce diversity statements for grants or job applications, which are reviewed before their discipline-related credentials are examined.
I have received numerous emails from faculty who are too afraid to speak out publicly. Two different faculty wrote to me under pseudonyms for fear their colleagues or administrators might learn that they supported the statements I made in my WSJ article.
This climate of censorship, cancellation, and fear is antithetical to free inquiry and free speech, which should be at the very foundation of universities. The current incursion of ideological policing is negatively impacting faculty scholarship and teaching, and we risk producing a generation of students who will emerge from university being afraid to question their own and others’ beliefs.
0 Comments